Photo by Solen Feyissa on Unsplash
The publication of Ofcom’s BBC Annual Report 2025-26 has prompted renewed discussion about how the UK’s main public service broadcaster is reaching audiences in the digital age. The report states that the BBC “has accelerated its digital-first news strategy which is helping attract online audiences, including on YouTube and social media platforms – for example, 43% of 16-24s say they have come across BBC news content on social media”.
But while Ofcom praises the BBC for reaching younger audiences online, there is little discussion about how news itself changes when it is produced for social media platforms rather than broadcast bulletins or conventional news websites. The BBC’s performance, in other words, is almost exclusively interpreted through the prism of audience reach rather than how well the BBC informs audiences about politics and public affairs.
The BBC claims that content produced for TikTok, YouTube and Instagram is subject to the same editorial standards and impartiality requirements as flagship programmes such as flagship programmes like the News at Ten or Today. Yet there has been little systematic research examining whether political journalism on social media adheres to the same impartiality standards as regulated broadcast news.
Our impartiality of news project at Cardiff University has been examining how political journalism is being adapted for social media and how duly impartial it is. We are systematically tracking how broadcasters produce political news for TikTok and comparing it with more conventional forms of broadcast journalism.
Our early findings suggest that the editorial logic of TikTok differs markedly from that of broadcast news. For example, stories that attract the most engagement often centre on human interest, spectacle and emotional reaction, while public-interest issues, policy debates and competing party viewpoints are given limited prominence.
On TikTok, non-political stories perform much better than those about UK politics. Between 1st September and 12th October, non-political stories from BBC News accumulated an average of 851,146 plays, compared to 625,365 for international political news and 359,559 for UK political news.
Of the top 50 most-viewed shorts, only one was about UK politics – a story about school students in Bicester petitioning Andy Burnham to ban school uniforms in porn.
Political stories on TikTok frequently take the form of fragments, short clips from political speeches, broadcast interviews, or programmes originally broadcast elsewhere. And unlike conventional broadcast reporting, short-form video usually focuses on a single political party and perspective, rather than multiple competing viewpoints within the same story.
Despite concerns that BBC resources are being diverted from flagship news programmes to support social media output, our analysis suggests that when TikTok videos feature senior journalists, this content is repurposed from other output, and dedicated TikTok videos are predominantly fronted by junior and specialist social media presenters.
Our study will continue to examine the BBC's most-viewed TikTok clips, the factors driving engagement and how successful the public service broadcaster is in reaching younger audiences online.
We will also examine how algorithmic recommendation engines shape the visibility of different political parties – addressing concerns that by prioritising algorithmically curated commercial platforms, the BBC loses a degree of editorial control over its output as it controls what gets posted but not what gets seen.
Our findings already raise questions about whether the BBC's model of due impartiality is being undermined on social media. Political news on TikTok appears less likely to expose audiences to a range of party political perspectives than routine coverage across TV, radio or online platforms. Moreover, engagement is often driven by snapshots, controversy and political personalities rather than substantive issues and policy debates that help audiences make sense of what is happening in the world.